Incorrect Resolution for Issue 17462

Status

resolved

Resolution

not fixable

Priority

normal

Severity

minor

Steps to reproduce

Description

Though Midway Atoll forms part of the Hawiian Archipelago geographically speaking, it is not part of the state of Hawaii itself. The state of Hawaii was created via the following act: “AN ACT TO PROVIDE FOR THE ADMISSION OF THE STATE OF HAWAI‘I INTO THE UNION, ACT OF MARCH 18, 1959, PUB L 86-3, 73 STAT 4.” Midway Atoll and several other remote areas with explicitly excluded under §2, thus: “…but said State shall not be deemed to include the Midway Islands, Johnston Island, Sand Island (off-shore from Johnston Island), or Kingman Reef, together with their appurtenant reefs and territorial waters.” A PDF of this legalisation is freely available online. Essentially these very remote places were deemed to be too awkward to be looked after by the new state’s administration, so were left to the Navy to look after until about 30 years ago when the DOI took over. The FWS currently manages the marine national park. The atoll even has its own zip code, with the “state” stated as “Minor Outlying Islands”: geo.mycyber.org/USA/midway-... According to the Turf Wiki the USA is “divided into 51 regions corresponding to the country's 50 states and the federal district District of Columbia” however the Minor Outlying Islands do not belong to ANY state and are an independent entity of their own, hence why I believe a 52nd region is required to cater for them. Thanks, Simon

Reported by

Issue ID

#17479

Date submitted

2025-06-17T02:32:26+02:00

Zone

Pihemanu in region Hawaii

Attachments

No attachments.

Related issues

related to #17462

Responses

Kingslayer

Date: 2025-06-17T07:14:16+02:00

You may be right but the geodata for our zones is assigned from open streetmap. And open streetmap has this as USA/Hawaii, and I can't invent new countries and areas, the tool does not allow me to.

Add comment or attachment

Comments or attachments cannot be added to this issue. If you think that this issue is not solved properly, please submit a new issue.


© 2012-2013. All rights reserved.