Zonerna can easily be taken by car on the road or from parking lot

Status

closed

Resolution

fixed

Priority

normal

Severity

minor

Steps to reproduce

Description

This zone should be moved about 100m West along the walking/biketrack to the other side of the road. Where it is, it is easily taken by car either from the parking lot or on the road. It is dangerous to leave it where it is. A zone should not be accessible from a road from within your car. Also the namn makes little sense. It was suggested as GränbyHund since it is next to an dog exercise area in the attached pictures.

Reported by

Issue ID

#3667

Date submitted

2015-12-27T18:29:19+01:00

Zone

Kaozone in region Uppsala

Attachments

Related issues

related to #4023, related to #5513

Responses

Munin

Date: 2015-12-27T18:30:02+01:00

☒ I think this is an important issue.

Munin

Date: 2015-12-27T18:34:42+01:00

Uploaded file Screenshot_2015-12-27-18-20-33.png.

Munin

Date: 2015-12-27T18:35:05+01:00

Borde flyttas hit

Uploaded file Screenshot_2015-12-27-18-20-19.png.

Hylaeus

Date: 2015-12-27T18:47:00+01:00

☒ I'm also affected by this issue.

☒ I think this is an important issue.

Roligare att ta zonen medan man tittar på lekande hundar än att stå uppe på en trafikerad bro eller irritera bilister på en parkeringplats.

StarDust

Date: 2015-12-27T19:12:18+01:00

I disagree. This zone is placed on a bike path and only by bouncing gps is it possible to take it from other locations than it is placed. The zone is also placed very attractively near the main entrance to Gränby Centrum which will lure many turfers to take the zone on their way in or out. Also, think of people with allergies not being able to take this zone when a lot of dogs are near.

Munin

Date: 2015-12-27T21:13:08+01:00

The argument from StarDust about allergies, are stupid, if you're so allergic to dogs, you would not be able to be outdoors! Pfff! This zone is today in a boring bicycle path crossing between two parking lots next to a shopping mall, nothing special in any way (according to your own guide lines about new zones). Next to the dog exercise area you are given a better view of the area, including the 'alluring' shopping mall (according to StarDust). And even if the reason behind the possiblity to take the zone on the car road is the gps bounching off the building, it should be moved to a place where that is less likely to happen. Zones should not be located where taking them can be a disturbance to car traffic.

StarDust

Date: 2015-12-27T23:58:25+01:00

If there is an area where there are more dogs, an allergic person is probably going to get a reaction, meeting a dog temporarily is completely different than meeting ten dogs. Setting that aside I still think that this is a great placement for a zone close to the mall for the shoppers to take. Moving it away from the mall will not attract people to take it as much since it will be 300 m or more away from the main entrance. I have not yet tried to take the zone, but I will tomorrow and report whether or not the building causes such GPS problems that it should be moved. The zone builder made a good choice in the placement on the bike path and is well within the guidelines of zone placement.

StarDust

Date: 2015-12-28T16:46:55+01:00

I took the zone today and confirm my previous statements. The zone is perfectly placed on the bike path. I also went to each side of the zone to check how far it really goes and my GPS was spot on, no bouncing. There is practically no chance that you can take the zone by car unless you drive down the bike road which in itself is quite tricky with obstacles blocking the road.

Weekendstone

Date: 2016-02-11T08:28:05+01:00

Jag har tagit zonen nu några gånger och tycker den ligger bra där den ligger nu på cykelvägen och naturligt mittemellan de 4 zonerna runt omkring. Om den ska flyttas så tycker jag i så fall att den ska flyttas på andra sidan gångtunneln, men då blir den inte lika naturlig att ta om man är i Gränby Centrum och handlar. Jag har inte lyckats tagit den med bil.

Munin

Date: 2016-02-24T10:40:19+01:00

De gräver i zonen ich den är inhägnad. Flytt är en rätt bra idé...

Uploaded file IMG_20160224_103938.JPG.

Spix

Date: 2016-03-15T20:00:41+01:00

Zon flyttad i annan issue (denna blev liggande och bortglömd pga zonmakarskifte)

Add comment or attachment

Comments or attachments cannot be added to this issue. If you think that this issue is not solved properly, please submit a new issue.


© 2012-2013. All rights reserved.